Thursday, December 23, 2021

Old Debate from 2012, citing goes on - Mismodeling Indo-European origins - and a discussions about Maria Gimbutas - videos


 Salvete Omnes,





right before Christmas - so this is this rather old video from 2012 - but it goes to the heart of the matter, i.e., debate on the origins of the Indo-Europeans and the politics of the academic world - eg my post about the November 2021AD article of the Tocharians etc.

So in 2012 The Science (and NYT followed with this article) published this article: Mapping the Origins and Expansion of the Indo-European Language Family - 

Two scholars: Martin W. Lewis & Asya Pereltsvaig, in this video they did a very pointed and excellently delivered critique  on the errors and falsities of that Science article at Stanford Univ.. this short lecture is a great voyage into the historic linguistics and the story of Indo-Europeans. 
But in spite of the soundness of their arguments the article from The Science keeps on being cited (as you can see from the PubMed link. 

Regarding the Kurgan theory there are many critics of the Gimbutas, Anthony et al., kurgan hypothesis  - like  this presenter.












Nota bene:  

James Mallory, David Anthony, and Dorcas Brown talking about Maria Gimbutas and her theories being vindicated - from UCLA October 2021. 

from more distant past - dr Anthony's Wheeled vehicles, horses, and Indo-European origins lecture from 2012.


Valete


Merry Christmas 2021

 Salvete Omnes,




so in spite of the scary and demonizing, bah, even terrorizing  rhethoric coming out of the 'free media' via tvs, radio and printed ones, we have survived yet another year. And hope for more - :)



Today is Christmas Eve - if  you are celebrating , then do enjoy your feast with the family, may it be full of joy and happiness.

Merry Christmas to you all, dear friends

Wesolych Swiat Bozego Narodzenia - wesolosci i humoru, pieknej Wigilii 

Feliz Navidad...

and some Sandro Botticelli masterpieces for your sore, from watching too much Netlifx and YT, eyes .. 



Valete

Taxcala Codex from the Smithsonian

 Salvete Omnes,



I think a short entry on this one. So I have a a nice little 'regalito' (a gift) of a link for  you this Christmas season - notwithstanding what our POTUS wished to us all a couple days ago.

so there it is - the Smithsonian Institution librarians have digitized the Mexican facsimile copy (edicion Alfredo Chavero & Genaro Lopez) of the Lienzo de Tlaxcala (Tlaxcala Codex) from 1892AD. Then the digitized album have been placed, yes, you guessed it, on the world digital library archive.org - here there is this link. You can download, copy and do whatever you desire and enjoy this old art and historical primary source.



Enjoy this work of beauty and drama, you can be  studying the horses there and then perhaps also entire beautifully drawn story painted by the indigenous North American  artists, created in the 1570sAD in Tlaxcala, then part of Spanish realm known as Nueva Espana (New Spain).



ps
Nota bene, have you known that there is  the Montezuma noble family in Latin America and Spain,  the direct descendants of the tlaotlani Montezuma II? well, you know the Spanish did not kill   and exterminate all indigenous people in the Americas, they even married them and created la Raza. The Spanish Black Legend, created by the XVI-XVIII centuries protestants in Europe (picked up by the Americans in the XIXc), made the Spanish and to some degree the Portuguese into those  monstrous genocidal killers and destroyers of all indigenous - which is  a false narrative and outright lie. You can read many a book on archive about this slanderous fabrication.

Merry Christmas to you, dear fellow net surfers and travelers - :) 

Valete

Saturday, December 18, 2021

Dr David Anthony on migrations in prehistoric Eurasia Steppe

 Salvete Omnes,




Today I came across this interview with dr David Anthony, one of my most favorite researchers on the prehistoric horses and Eurasian steppe people  - How ancient DNA revived ancient migrations in archaeology.

[Abstract]  Among archaeologists, until recently migration was regarded as a simplistic (at best) and even racist (at worst) way to explain culture change in the ancient past. Ancient DNA recovered from prehistoric humans has shown, however, that our ancestors moved long distances in demographically significant migrations that had profound effects on food, gender, architecture, and regional genetics. Integration between modern migration studies and archaeological interpretation is necessary to better inform archaeologists about the dynamics of these encounters. 






Nota bene his 1990 article - Migration in Archaeology 



and the most recent article available 'libre' -   Dairying enabled Early Bronze Age Yamnaya steppe expansions (Nature). 



Valete


Friday, December 17, 2021

Horse of Cortez and his conquistadors - Tenochtitlan 4

 Salvete Omnes,



a short entry - continuing with the horses of Conquest - the English translation of the 16 horse list as presented by  Bernal Diaz del Castillo:

the first translation in this series comes from the 1844 British translation by John Ingram Lockhart - 








the following one from the XX century,   published in the land of the Mexica

Alfred Percival Maudslay's 1908 translation published in Mexico City, USofMexico- 


nota bene Alfred P. Maudslay was a famous Maya archaeology pioneer 

there are  more translations that could be of interest, so I will copy some of them in my future posting 


Valete


Thursday, December 16, 2021

Lecture on the armour - dr Toby Capwell

Salvete Omnes,



a nice treat to all armor aficionados and art historian types et al., - dr Toby (Tobias) Capwell is currently delivering a lecture - via The Wallace Collection page on Ytube - on the  armor made by the famous armorer  Konrad Seusenhofer et consortes at Innsbruck. 



Here an earlier video on the Seusenhofer armor samples at the Wallace Collection.
So if you can then join the lecture - :) 



Nota bene Toby Capwell et al.,  An Experimental Investigation of Late Medieval Combat with the Couched Lance via academia.edu .


Valete

Wednesday, December 15, 2021

Los Caballos de Cortes et consortos - Tenochtitlan 3

 Salvete Omnes,



so in the last post - Tenochtitlan 2 - about the conquest of Mexico I already landed the horses brought by the Cortes expeditionary armada on the banks or beaches of the Tabasco coast.

I am going to list these horses, thanks to Benral Diaz del Castillo (or Cortes himself and one French researcher proposes) and his famous account of the 1519-1521 conqueest.

The list today will be in Spanish, followed by posts with translation into English (there are two or three good ones) and finally one in Polish(which should be fun to translate).




Spanish original -from the  capitulo XXIII (23) from the Spanish edition AD 1862 (Madrid) and I checked it against Miguel Leon-Portilla 's digital edition (all available on archive.org) :



so we have:

1. un caballo castano zaino

2. una yegua castana muy buena

3. una yegua rucia de buena carrera

4. la rabona, yegua rucia de bunea carrera, muy revuelta y de bunea carrera

5. un caballo castano oscuro, harto beno

6. un caballo alazan tostado, no fue para cosa de guerra

7. un caballo castano oscuro, gran corredor y revuelto

8 . un caballo castano claro, tresalvo, no fue bueno

9. una yegua rucia, machorra, pasadera aunque corria poco

10. un caballo castano oscuro muy bueno y gran corredor 

11.  un caballo castano, perfecto castano, que corria muy bien.

12. un caballo overo, labrado de las manos y era bien revuelto

13. un caballo overo algo sobre morcillo, no salio bueno

14. un caballo muy bueno, de color castano, algo claro y buen corredor

15. un muy buen caballo oscuro que decian 'el Arriero'. este fue un de los buenos caballos que pasamos en la armada

16. una yegua castana - pario en el navio.



Valete

Tuesday, December 14, 2021

Czarniecki , Pasek et consortes - crossing the sea to Als

 Salvete Omnes,



a little remembrance of the Deluge and Polish cavalry action - on December 14, 1658 AD Stefan Czarniecki, commander of the Polish Crown army division in Danish Kingdom, ordered his horse banners to cross the open Baltic Sea waters, circa 500 meters wide straits, onto the island of Als, where the Swedish invaders were holed up. The cavalrymen and their horses crossed the straits and having surprised the Swedish enemy with their resolve and bravery and being somewhat immune to the freezing cold, won the day. 



This event was described in some detail by one of the most famous Polish diarists of the XVII century, Jan Ch. Pasek, who was also a pancerny kozak companion serving under Stefan Czarniecki during the Deluge and this Danish  campaign.



The event was so unusual in Polish history, a very land based nation at that time, that when 150 years later Jozef Wybicki wrote Mazurek Dabrowskiego,  current Polish national anthem, he included this feat in the text of the song.
In Polish art history this campaign was popular with the artists, especially during the XIX century  realism period.



[in Polish]

Wydawnictwo InfortEditions wydalo rok temu prace polskiego historyka Wiktora Czermaka na temat wyprawy Czarnieckiego do Danii.

W tej edycji opus Czermaka sa moje dwie ilustracje nawiazujace do opowiesci Jana Chryzostoma Paska o przeprawie na Als.



Valete

Stepanova & Marsadolov - Mongol saddles from south Siberia

 Salvete Omnes,

a short entry -
there is a new article that E.V. Stepanova, researcher the Hermitage Museum, published on her academia page.

the article is about the Mongol period (XII-XIV centuriesAD) saddles from Chasovennaya Gora near Krasnoyarsk, south Siberia, Russian Federation.

Below you can find one of the images included in the article - the new reconstruction of  one of the saddles by E.V. Stepanova


Valete

Monday, December 13, 2021

Maize and hay - Tenochtitlan 2

 Salvete Omnes,



so here the 2nd post in the theme of the 500 years anniversary of the conquest of the Mexica (Aztecs) and coming of horses to the Americas:

Soldier and chronicler Bernal Diaz del Castillo is our primary authority on the  horses collected, bought,  gathered and embarked in Cuba prior to Cortes' armada sailing of into the western Caribbean sea.

In all large Caribbean Island -  Cuba,  Puerto Rico and Santo Domingo, and Jamaica the Spanish horses brought from the Spanish realms (Castilian Andalusian ports in the southern Kingdom of Castile) found a veritable paradise, meadows and pastures to grow, procreate and prosper towards a much better conformation than the stock they originated from. 

In his Cuban base of Havana(San Cristobal de la Habana) Hernan Cortes,(native of Medellin, Spain) acting under the governor Velazquez of Cuba orders and instructions, had gathered men (over 600 including sailors, 200 Indians from Cuba), bought equipment of war (especially the quilted cotton jackets against the natives' sling stones, clubs,  arrows and spears), foodstuffs (like casava bread, maize, pork ), 11 ships (of various sizes) and 16 horses and mares from the limited adult stock available on the island (Cuba was taken and consequently conquered in 1511AD).  Presumably the island was rather poor in horses available for war that were on the market. 
Horse fodder was to consist of  maize (Indian Corn) and hay, presumably gathered in Cuba.

It was to be the third expedition to the mainland ordered and sent by governor Velazquez (1517 and 1518 respectively). 
Already rebellious from his good governor Velasquez  don Hernan Cortez ordered the expeditionary fleet to sail of on February 10, 1519AD. They landed their longboats, as the ships stayed anochred on the sea, near the town of Ponchan on the Tabasco river coast on March 12, 1519AD. And started disembarking horses - the next day they fought first battle, that is on the continent of North America these Spanish horses were used for the first time against the natives of Mexico. With the horses rested, saddled and riders armed the mortal combat was about to enjoin between the native defenders and Spanish invading conquistadors. 

The horse had be be embarked and disembarked into and from the ships - but then carrying horse on the naval transports was nothing new in the Old World. The Spanish, starting with  the famous Portuguese(most likely) in Spanish service aka  Cristobal Colon, brought  horses, cows, goats, swine to the Caribbean islands and their war horses took part in the conquests of  the Arawak and Carib native islands in the Caribbean.

Already  3000 years before,  pharaoh Thutmose III of Egypt's 18th Dynasty( of New Kingdom) had special naval transports built to ship his chariots and horses up the Levantine coast into Syria.

 In the later periods the Persians (eg Marathon expedition), then the Greeks(eg Athenian invasion of Sicily), Romans (eg invasion of Britain), Byzantines( eg reconquest of the Holy Land and Syria in 10th century), and later Medieval Europeans(eg reconquest of Sicily, the Crusades XI-XIVc)) and Islamic invaders(eg conquest of Sicily VIII-Xc) shipped war horses over the sea.

In the XVI century Spanish and Portuguese vessels sailing the oceans and seas had the horses on board  suspended in a system of slings, pulleys and hobbles, and for this occasion we have a  page from Trachtenbuch des Christoph Weiditz, an album of Spanish Empire costumes drawn and painted in Spain  by a Geman artist Weiditz circa 1530-40AD.



Now, the painting by Hans Memling - Seven Joys of the Virgin - shows horses unsaddled, embarked on a rowing longboats, and from these boats loaded onto a ship anchored at sea (my maritime and marine vocabulary is rather weak and wanting, so pardon my ignorance of the ship etc terminology).

to be continued

Valete


Sunday, December 12, 2021

Roubaud and his teachers 1878-80

 Salvete Omnes,
having started with Franz Roubaud and his equestrian art I have decided to continue with his Munich education  and other topics, as they  interconnect with the Munich Academy, and allow me to bring forward some fine artists who taught and practiced their art in the sunny capital of Bavarian Kingdom in its glory days.



Our Odessa born young Roubaud - born in 1856 to French parents -  decided to travel to Bavaria to enroll in the Munich Art Academy. His teachers there were to be Carl/Karl von Piloty, Otto Seitz and Wilhelm von Diez. He saved money working in the Black Sea bustling seaport and perhaps received some from his parents, albeit Hans-Peter Buhler, author of a book about the Polish artists circle in Munich titled 'Jager, Kosaken und Polnische Reitter' (1993) stated that Franz was very gifted with pens , pencils and brushes from the very age, and starting at 6 y.o. his parents had him taught formal lessons in drawing,  while he also made a trip to Tbilisi on the river Kura, then Russian Georgia. There he first saw the fascinating world of the Caucasus Mountains and multi-ethnic world of the borderland between Asia and Europe.

ad rem, his Munich academy teachers:
von Piloty










Seitz



von Diez









Franz continued his studies at Munich  until money run out , and in spite of the fact that he was one of the most promising students there (Piloty issued a official diploma in 1880, with a note invoking an urgent need for this disciple's financial support, which failed to materialize), so our young artists left for Odessa to make some more money there.

He would be back in Munich at the end of 1881, and this time he joins the Polish artists circle, with Jozef Brandt at its helm. 

Nota bene a very large scan of one of his paintings.

to be continued

Valete